Mapping the social networks of undergraduate STEM students

• Authors: Adam Dilla, Zena Donovan, Dylan Neider, & Dustin Thoman

• Time & Location:
Western Psychological Association 97th Annual Convention | Sacramento, California
Fri, April 28, 2:15 to 3:45pm
Sheraton Grand, Downtown

• Abstract:
There are widespread racial disparities in many STEM fields, which occur as a direct result of differences in the way students select and persist in their college majors. One explanation for why certain students are more likely to persist in STEM is that they leave because they have a lower sense of belonging. This lack of belonging in science fields may result not only from in-class experiences, but potentially also broader differences in how people think about their social networks related to their science identities. Because social support is crucial to a student’s particular path and success in college, we compared the social networks of underrepresented minority STEM students (URM; African American and Latino/Hispanic) to those of students well represented in STEM (Caucasian and Asian).
Undergraduate students who had declared science majors (n = 239, 44% URM) were recruited from introductory physics, biology, and chemistry classrooms at a large Hispanic Serving Institution. Using a hierarchical mapping technique (see Antonucci), they were asked to “think about [their] major and experiences at school” and write the names of the members of their social support network. They wrote the relationship of each person to their name, and placed more important people near the center of the map, with less important people toward the periphery. We categorized each support person into a discrete relationship type: family, peer, or superior. Within peers and superiors, relationships were categorized as either academic or non-academic. We found that URM students listed more family members than did other students (F = 5.025, p = .026), and they also listed a greater number of family members relative to other categories of people. Meaning, while URM students did not list more total people in their network than other students (p > .8), they listed relatively more family members in comparison to superiors, peers, academics, and nonacademics (p’s = .066, .010, .106, .011). These findings suggest that, for URM students, family members make up a greater proportion of their school-related support system. This is important because, if URM students are more heavily influenced by their family when it comes to school-related identities, they likely have a harder time compromising between the cultural identities they have at home and the academic identities they have at school. This discrepancy can make it harder for them to feel like they belong in STEM fields, thus contributing to their lack of persistence and underrepresentation.


1 2
October 16th, 2017

Ariana Hernandez is admitted to the NIH IMSD Program at SDSU

Ariana Hernandez is admitted to the competitive NIH IMSD Program at SDSU! IMSD (Initiative for Maximizing Student Development) program is […]

July 22nd, 2017

Media Coverage

Association for Psychological Science

Press from our latest publication from Project CURE! Minority Students and the Culture of Research: “What is clear from these […]

June 23rd, 2017


Psychological Science

Research microcultures as socialization contexts for underrepresented science students Thoman, D.B., Muragishi, G.A., & Smith, J.L.   Abstract How much […]

June 1st, 2017

Matthew Jackson accepted an Assistant Professor position at CSULA

Matthew C. Jackson accepted an assistant professor position at Department of Psychology, California State University Los Angeles!

June 1st, 2017

Dylan Neider received 2017 SDSU Summer Undergrad Research Assistantship

Undergraduate Research Assistant Program at SDSU is designed to encourage student participation in a broad range of scholarly and academic […]

April 30th, 2017

Jeanette Zambrano received Sally Casanova Scholarship

The scholarship is named after Sally Casanova, who founded the Pre-Doctoral Scholar Program in 1989 to increase diversity within the pool […]

April 20th, 2017

Media Coverage

Washington Post

Our work appeared in the Washington Post! Here is a piece of the article:   …Within science, technology, engineering and […]

April 4th, 2017


WPA 2017 Annual Convention | April 28

Mapping the social networks of undergraduate STEM students • Authors: Adam Dilla, Zena Donovan, Dylan Neider, & Dustin Thoman • Time […]

April 4th, 2017


AERA 2017 Annual Meeting | April 28, 2:15pm

Perceived Faculty Support in Freshman Year Boosts First-Generation College Students’ Belonging and Persistence in Science • Authors: Garam Lee, Gregg […]

April 4th, 2017


AERA 2017 Annual Meeting | April 27, 12:00pm

Talking About Science Interest: Appraisals of Positive Responsiveness Impact Women’s Science Interest Development • Authors: Christina Curti, Jeanette Zambrano, Garam […]